Weeping

Can writing words wipe away the sadness? Can reading them help with the healing? We have to at least try.

I am wondering why I don’t

          write poetry

          Since my son died.

          My heart

          is a wasteland

          of weariness

          Can I weather

          the frozen mind.

Like a strong wind

that suddenly stops

My grief is woven

in between the heart

and mind. 

Will the writing ever work

again.

No longer weary

with the weight of sadness.

Will the weeping ever cease?

Celebrations Remembered

Birthdays, Bar Mitzvahs, and Bat Mitzvahs stand out across time, each reflecting life as it was then, feeling so permanent in the moment yet always changing. The shifts that blurred across the days, weeks, and years now look so clear in retrospect.

As I recall them here, they tumble one into the other, each representing their own sort of joy even in the midst of heartache.

The first birthday party I remember I was six years old.  My father was making a 30th birthday party for my mother; he was thirty-two.  I remember thinking how old they were.  My parents had a terrible marriage but I would like to believe that, at least once, she was grateful and happy and expressed those feelings to my father, who was always trying to please her.  Eventually, of course, he stopped trying to please and just left.

The next birthday I remember was my brother Marvin’s.  It was his Bar Mitzvah.    At thirteen, he was already grown, tall, handsome, and already shaving. He had those good-looking Hollywood playboy looks.  The ritual and the party afterwards were symbols of the culture we were part of rather than any deep religious significance.  Marvin was a boy, their first boy, and something to be joyous about.  I was five and my sister four when Marvin was born, and I still remember my father calling everyone and shouting, “It’s a boy, it’s a boy.  Finally, we have a boy.”

Only girls attended my sweet sixteen birthday party.  I sometimes get it confused with my bridal shower; one of them was at Tavern on the Green in New York.  I was chubby then and not very joyful about anything.  I was anything but sweet, good, yes, but definitely not sweet.

And then there were all the yearly parties for my children, Marian, Stephen and Beth.   There were those endless parties in the living room.  Once I hired a teenage clown.  There were story telling parties and scavenger hunts.  We even had parties at a local park with barbecues and baseball for Steve.  If we were lucky enough to avoid a party, we would take one or two friends of the birthday child to some special event instead. 

When my youngest, Beth, was about five, the neighbor across the street had a party for her five year old.   She invited everyone on the block except Beth.  The next summer I invited her daughter to Beth’s party and she felt very uncomfortable and guilty, at least that is what she expressed to another neighbor.  Good, that was just what I wanted to happen.

Then came those surprise parties my friends and I made for each of our forty-year old husbands.  I thought the one I made for Charly was very successful.  But, shortly after the party, he asked me for a divorce.  The same thing happened to quite a few of my friends who had similar parties for their husbands’ fortieth birthdays.   From then on, we advised everyone we knew who was contemplating such a party against it.  We warned people that those parties were the kiss of death and were a prelude to middle age angst.

Marian was Bat Mitzvah and Steve Bah Mitzvah in the same synagogue a year apart.  We were divorced by then and all I could afford was a party afterwards in my home.  Charly forbade any of his family from coming.  We kept a stiff upper lip about it all but it surely was a symbol of the legacy of divorce and very sad.

By the time Beth was sweet sixteen, Charly was remarried and living in a lavish home in a neighboring community.  He planned a formal party for Beth at his house.  Beth and I had so much fun buying her first formal dress.  And he was gracious, he invited us all, some of my friends, and even my mother and her second husband.  As soon as I walked into the house Charly told me how many bedrooms and bathrooms his grand new house had.  It was big, but very tacky.  He had no idea how I might feel seeing this house while I received hardly any alimony and child support.  The neighbors complained about the music from the live band and the dancing had to stop.  Later that night, Beth and most of her friends and Charley’s stepsons ended up on my living room floor spending the night.

My birthday, November 26th, always falls sometime on the Thanksgiving weekend and everyone came home no matter where they lived.  When I was sixty, my children made me a surprise birthday party.  I can still feel how stunned I was at one Thanksgiving when I opened the card to find the picture of a computer.  What I appreciated was their image of me.   So many of the people I know are snow birds, or blue birds, or goofy birds.  But my children think of me as this busy person uncovering new worlds via the internet and wide world web which is a gift in itself. 

Another time, my family gave me an expensive music system.  My family surprised me with a party when I was sixty, gave me a new computer when I was seventy, and a music system when I was seventy-five.  I could hardly wait for what I would get when I became eighty.  Perhaps they would think of a new car, an airplane, who knows what.

The Spaces of My Soul

No matter how big the house, there’s one room where it seems everyone ends up. The kitchen. Big or small, it’s where people naturally gather. Maybe it’s because it’s the source of the food. Maybe it’s because we have so much in common there. Regardless, a full kitchen is a happy place. And even when I’m on my own, I find it’s where I want to be.

My kitchen is my home

The best light to read with

A table to eat and write on

Food near me

The telephone a step or two away.

I hardly cook

Even in my kitchen.

Easy access to the tidbits, snacks

and wholly fattening things.

The kitchen is my home

Calm, peaceful, solid.

Reading the morning newspapers

Writing a story

Answering the telephone.

In the kitchen

I live my life

With almost everything I need.

The New York Times, The Globe

And the book I may be reading

Alone, my life, my heart,

Live on and on

In this small space.

The kitchen.

Shadows of My Life

The shadows of my life stream by


The lights and darks of my old ties


Blacks and whites, they seem to last


Beyond the strum and stress and cries.


The pain and triumphs of the past


The house I thought was warm and vast


Now small and simple and so dim


Shadows that are hard to grasp.


These shadows shape my dreams of him


What was true and what was sin


But shadows fade and then unfold


It’s time to let new life begin.


Which shadows should I keep and hold


What stories should I let be told


I grasp the new becoming bold


I grasp the new becoming bold.


What Am I Afraid Of?

There is a shift in perspective that comes as we move through the years. One day seems much like the last until you look back across the span and see how much has changed. This poem captures my perspective in this moment after so many decades on this earth.

My Mortality

I’m afraid of

          nothingness

Of not seeing my

          children and

          grandchildren and

          great-grandchildren

bloom, as they add

beauty to our lives.

New babies for the world.

In the background

          always there

My fears, my lack

          of courage.

Will I die?  When?

How?

I go on day after

          day

with my unfinished life.

          Seeing friends,

          reading books,

And trying not to be afraid.

Epilogue

How does one sum up an entire memoir? Is it possible to capture what you meant to say or is this final chapter just a follow-up? For me, the memoir was about more than recalling the past. It was about seeing the full picture. This is an excerpt from the last part of my book, The Myth of the Yellow Kitchen.

The gift of returning to the past led to greater understanding of the present, the one life I have, and my place in the larger scenario.

The book was written over a long period of time. For me, time was needed to face the issues and emotions of those early years with an honesty that only distance can bring. Through my writing I learned to rethink my views of gender, relationships and Identity.

Before the divorce, I tried so hard to be the ideal wife and mother — making drapes, taking cooking lessons, caring for my children, and fulfilling all the fantasies I had of the yellow kitchen. I never thought about what I needed to realize my own abilities.

“Give your husband your pay check,” friends advised me when I first started teaching. At that time, my husband, Charly, held a psychology internship in various New York State institutions and did not make much money. But did her really need my paycheck to safeguard his masculinity? And what about my feelings of confidence as a professional and decision-maker? In the fifties and sixties, I never disputed the idea of fixed gender roles.

The divorce, such a tragedy for me at that time, became the impetus for growth, independence and the development of my abilities. I did grow. I did change. I moved from the traditional view of a woman’s role in the forties and fifties to an independent, professional woman in the seventies, eighties, and nineties.

I have been fortunate to have had several long relationships wth men after the divorce. WIth each relationship, I was reminded how men were often socialized to a view of masculinity that was almost impossible to attain. The myths about male sexuality were particularly difficult for them. For me, on the other hand, the feminist movement portrayed models and images that helped me formulate new conceptions of both male and female roles.

This all became clearer to me as I began to write. I started writing more than thirty years ago when I sold my house and went from room to room remembering what happened there, who we were, and how developed. Still, it took years before I could embrace writing, years of working hard to keep it all afloat and taking care of the children. Then, there was little time and energy to write. Now, writing fuels my passion and creativity. Often, I am at the computer at five in the morning. The gift of returning to the past leads to a greater understanding of the present, the one life I have, and my place in the larger scenario.

As I look back over my life, even now many years later, I am reminded again and again of that night long ago when Beth was sick, really sick in the middle of the night and I had to rethink who I was and what I needed to do. Then I found my strength in helping Beth. From where does the strength come now to face the ambiguities ahead?

Sometimes the blessings can get lost in the murkiness of longevity, the shadows of unexpected ailments, the vagueness of where am I going, if anywhere. But each day, I try and reconnect with the strengths that emerged after the divorce the force to get a doctorate when I had no money and three young children, and the power to enjoy the magic and mystery of life.

The Children are Grown, But a Mother Remembers

It’s been a long time since I’ve sent anyone to school, but seeing all the young students passing by with their backpacks, I am reminded of what it was like in those hectic days. This is something I wrote looking back long ago. It’s from my book The Myth of the Yellow Kitchen.

I often think about those days long-ago of mothering. I want to capture it all again, tie a shoe, cuddle a child, kiss a cheek. When they were young, they used to complain, “You’re not listening.” And I try to listen all the time, to who they are, human, loving, complex.

For me, there is always something of a mystery about the children and how they turned out. How come they are all such good cooks with different styles of cooking? Why did all three intermarry? How did these products of the 60s, flower children, the experimenters with drugs, with sex, with lifestyles, learn to be such wonderful parents? They ended up liking themselves, liking each other, and liking me.

I feast my eyes on my children, grown beautiful, building an order to their lives, having their own children. I feast my eyes on the richness of the harvest and the miracle of it all.

Who am I? Asking in Retirement

Some time not so long ago, I was asked to give a speech about my perspective on life given all that I’ve lived through. It’s not the sort of thing that’s easy to summarize. It involves a lot of questions. I am sharing some excerpts for others who might be asking those same questions.

For me, the study of aging is an evolving process adding new ideas and perspectives over time.  Probably I have more questions than answers.  My basic question is what is the meaning and purpose of this stage of life. 

But first some background.                                                                                        

I was a faculty member at Empire State College, a branch of the State University of New York, and worked primarily with adult students.  Many of them were dealing with questions about aging, aging related to their parents or themselves.  No one on the faculty had experience in this area.  I decided to apply for a sabbatical to research and study aging.  I was interested in the topic both for myself and the people I was teaching.  I researched many questions about aging and participated in a week-long workshop with Elizabeth Kubler Ross on Death and dying. 

When I moved to Boston, I became involved with the program at Harvard, the Harvard Institute for Learning in Retirement.  Aging was a forbidden word even though everyone was retired and could be considered the older generation.  I, with others, initiated a discussion program called Conversations on Aging and led several workshops on different aspects of the concept.  I also taught several courses on aging at HILR and Brandeis.  With others, we produced a book, New Pathways for Aging, and changed way aging is discussed.  For this book twenty-seven people wrote essays on some aspect of their lives.  At least for a time, we changed the way aging is viewed at one institution. 

The New Age of Aging

We are living now in a generation that I call the new age of aging.    It is new because we are living longer than any previous generation and can live for 20 or 30 years after retirement.  Not only are we living longer, we are also physically and mentally vigorous.  What are the possibilities for these long years of retirement? 

Theorists and researchers who focused on life stages were prominent in the 60s and 70s.  They perceived each stage of life with a focus, a role, a time to go to school, a time to build a career, to marry, and have children.  Life after 65 was almost an impossible dream.  For example, Freud framed the meaning of life as work and love.  For a long time, I thought that was brilliant but what happens in this framework for people no longer working.    

How the Roles Change

For our generation, a generation living longer, are there roles we should be fulling. What fits our lives now?  What are our tasks during this stage of life?  The American dream, retire at 65, play tennis and golf works for some people.  But it is a long time to play golf, if you live to 80 or 90.  Now even 100 does not seem unlikely.

Who are we as individuals, as parents, as grandparents, as citizens, as members of Temple Israel?  How did I change after retirement?

We are living healthier lives, healthier than any previous generation and maintain an intellectual vigor that is actualized in such programs as HILR, the Harvard program and TILLI.  There are also programs for retired people at Brandeis, MIT and Regis in the Boston community. 

Archibald MacLeish, the poet, asked a question during an interview with Benjamin DeMott in 1979, 

“Now if you realize this—what the purpose of your art is—you come to see that you are laboring at your art not only to make works of art but to make sense of your life–those dark and bewildering moments of experience.  Of course, you want to be admired—to be a great poet.  But who is a great poet?  Maybe a handful in the world’s history.  So that’s irrelevant.  What’s really going to come out of your work is something else.  If you have succeeded at all, you have become—however small a part—of the consciousness of your time.  Which is enough.  No?  The question at the center, the poet’s question remains the same:  who am I?” 

What a great question.

Who am I? Who are we? 

What is my identity now that I am no longer raising a family or nurturing a career? 

What are my choices?  What are our choices?

What are the challenges?  What are the opportunities? 

How did you define yourself before retirement?  How do you define yourself now?

Stan Davis, now deceased, wrote thirteen books, taught at the Harvard School of Business, was an international consultant, and was one of the authors of New Pathways.  He wrote:

“The time since retiring has been a slow process, letting go of a self-image that had evolved and developed over four decades and finding a new one.” Because older adults face a roleless role they often have a diminished sense of identity and personal worth. 

Letting go of a self-image framed by work is a difficult transition.  These extra years that we have do not automatically mean happiness and a great life.  We have to take an active role in thinking about how we want to manage these extra years of good fortune.  

What is Loneliness?

Rhoada Wald, author of The House Loved Us, reflects on the sorrows and joys of life as her perspective changes. It’s a journey filled with unexpected twists and turns.

I just heard that Jane died.  We met long ago in a class at Columbia and have been friends for almost forty years.  She died of a heart attack and was found lying on the kitchen floor alone.  Her sister emailed me the news about her death, just the facts, nothing else.  Such is loss today.  It is lonely to know a person is gone, gone forever, and no one to talk to about Jane, about our strange and long friendship, about Jane’s life, her marriage, her divorce, her life in Israel, her conversion to strict orthodoxy, and much, much more.  But I am almost accustomed to new deaths.  They happen all the time now.  Jane lived on the fifth floor of a house in Berkeley with no elevator and I always wondered how she climbed the stairs with her fragile heart. 

She married an internationally known, brilliant mathematician who also became involved in Jewish religious orthodoxy in later life.  That’s how they met.  I was the woman who escorted Jane everywhere including the mikvah the day before their wedding..  I had never been in a mikvah before but understood the myth—wash away all sins.  They didn’t stay together for long, they divorced after five years in Israel where the internationally known mathematician was revered and honored.  I never liked him.

Jane’s doctorate was from Princeton and she researched and wrote her dissertation at Berkeley on culture.  She was forever putting her concept of culture into a book on California but it never came to pass, although she always said, “I am thinking about it.”

I have so many stories about Jane, but some stand out.  She began her adult life with the cult culture of California and slowly moved to Jewish orthodoxy.  She came to visit me once on a weekend.  When she opened the refrigerator that Saturday morning, the light was on.  She started screaming at me to have someone turn the light off.  I thought to myself, “She wants the refrigerator light turned off, well, that’s easy.“  She would not let me do it, I was Jewish.  Someone was in my house at that time, someone not Jewish and Jane was comfortable with Cecilia turning off the refrigerator light.  At the end of that scenario, I told her lovingly but with the determination that she could visit me anytime, but never again on a Jewish Sabbath or Jewish holiday.

      

The Stages of Mourning

At this stage of life, it is almost impossible not to think about the past.  Suddenly, I remember someone and think about that person for a very long time. 

Today I remember all those deaths, Jane, Gloria, Sylvia, Sidney, and Gene.  My life can be told through those deaths.  There are many more, my sister, Milly, my brother, Sam, my Aunt Dotty, my mother, and my father—one is enough to tell the story and is the metaphor for all.  I miss Milly, she was always there, to help, to smile, to make me laugh, to encourage me with my writing.  One night, when I was young, Aunt Dotty came to give me a kiss before I fell asleep.  “What are those tears on the pillow” she wanted to know?  And now twenty-five years later, I think of my mother all the time.  I want to pick up the phone and say hello like I used to.  I am the matriarch now, the oldest one in all the families and that is reassuring and unsettling. 

Motherhood goes on forever.  It never dies.  My son gets sick and I worry the way I always worried but now I keep the worry to myself.

This year, particularly last summer, I have learned to find some peace in solitude.  Like May Sarton, sometimes being alone feels replenishing.  I get up when I want, eat at unusual times, watch TV late in the night or never watch it.  I have only myself to please.  But sometimes I feel the pain of acute loneliness, solitude troubles the heart and the soul and I want to weep. 

I Am Lucky

Charly left when Beth was three, Stephen eight, and Marian nine.  He saw the children on a schedule after the divorce but was not really involved in their daily care.

In spite of everything, they have blossomed.  Not that there weren’t some issues and problems along the way.  There always are.  Marian and Beth both have masters in their fields and Stephen is an attorney. 

They have blossomed as parents, in marriage, and in each of their careers.  They have managed to deal with the problems, raise wonderful children who are now grown and involved in their own careers, find ways to take care of the issues of marriage when they arise and care for me when needed.  I am in their lives.  I am lucky to have my three children settled in one place.  We are a family here in Boston.

As Time Goes By – The Mystery of Aging

Bits and Pieces of Being Older

 Suddenly, at least it seems suddenly, I am a member of a new generation, an older generation who is living longer, longer than my grandparents, longer than my mother and father, longer than anyone I ever knew, even longer than my younger siblings. 

I don’t really feel old, whatever feeling old means. To me it is a great big mystery.  Before this time of life, I had many roles, a wife, a career, a parent, a friend.  There doesn’t seem to be any rules or roles for this stage of life.  Some people believe older people have wisdom.  But what is wisdom?  Is it simply living longer that makes one wise?

I have more questions than answers.

What is ageism?  It is the descriptor that chronological age is what it is all about and that this stage of life is about decline and loss.  It is not the truth, it is a stereotype because people of any age are different from one another.  Like sexism and racism, ageism is prejudice. 

Am I Growing Old?

Now, I am walking seventy laps rather than one hundred.  I swim thirty laps when I used to swim seventy.  Should I keep trying to keep up with the earlier days?  Growing older means thinking about mortality, my mortality, and that is so difficult.

I decided to make a Rosh Hashanah dinner again.  So many people are not here, Kay and Don, Hy and Sheila and we will miss them.  I have done it for at least forty years.  This year Rosh Hashanah was a bit different because some of the people who came every year did not and people who had never joined us before came.  It was wonderful, the feelings of community, of different generations talking together.  We talked about hope and the problems of our country.  I know I won’t be here in ten years so I might as well do it now.  Everyone loved being here together but we missed the ones who were not. 

Two grandchildren are getting married next year.  Will I make it?  Will I dance at their weddings? 

A New Horizon

What is ageism?  It is the descriptor that chronological age is what it is all about and that this stage of life is about decline and loss.  It is not the truth, it is a stereotype because people of any age are different from one another.  Like sexism and racism, ageism is prejudice.       

Each morning I get up and think, “well what will it be today?”  What new adventure?  What part of my body will echo the years gone past, the running, swimming, and long hikes?  

At this stage of life, there is so much freedom—to do whatever I want to do and can afford, to go to the movies, meet friends for dinner, join a club, a group, a class, teach a class.  My options are infinite; I just have to imagine what I want to do. what I can do.  This is the last phase, I will try to do my best.

Letters to My Family